The 7 Best Organic & Non-Toxic Mattresses in a Box

Of the 200 mattress in a box companies vying for your dollars, only a tiny fraction are non-toxic and made with organic materials. Here are our top picks for the best non-toxic mattresses in a box with Made Safe Certification to ensure the highest standards.

Our criteria

Check out our recommendations below for an organic, non-toxic mattresses that can seriously upgrade your sleep, won’t harm your indoor air quality, and that will save you money in the long-run.

All our choices below are:

1. Made with organic materials including GOTS cotton, GOTS wool, GOLS/FSC organic latex and other organic materials where relevant and available
2. Free of chemical flame retardants – we have prioritized Made Safe Certification
3. Free of chemical treatments such as toxic stain repellents and antibacterial chemicals
4. Highly rated by customers
5. Reasonably priced

As always at Leaf Score, we strongly favor companies that demonstrate a robust and comprehensive approach to sustainability, rather than those that make a ton of problematic products and then launch one ‘organic’ mattress in a fit of greenwashing.

look for made safe certification

Most consumers looking for a non-toxic mattress are concerned about VOCs, chemical flame retardants, and off-gassing and want as

pristine a product as possible. The best way to vet mattress manufacturers is to verify their products carry the most stringent certifications. It is for this reason that we prioritized Made Safe certification in formulating this list. The Made Safe certification is rigorous and scientific, screening products for more than 6,500 banned or Restricted List substances. This certification has a Red List significantly larger than the European Union’s restricted list of substances and hundreds of times larger than those restricted by the U.S. Food & Drug Administration and the Environmental Protection Agency combined. Most mattress listicles rely too heavily on Greenguard Gold, a certification which carries some weight, but which has become less useful for consumers.

Our top picks

1

Evaya Organic Mattress

Leaf Score

Eco-Institut and Made Safe Certified, will never off-gas, and certified to be free of even trace amounts of hazardous chemicals. Manufactured using EverEden Premium wool sourced from New Zealand farmers.

View on LeafScore Essentials

At a glance:

• Materials: GOTS certified cotton, organic EverEden wool, FSC certified talalay latex, individually wrapped steel coils 
• Certifications: GOTS, GOLS, Made Safe, GreenGuard Gold, Climate Neutral certified, FSC, Responsible Wool Standard, Formaldehyde Free (UL), Eco Institut, Fair Trade
• Firmness: Gentle-firm (or medium-firm)
• Best for: Stomach-sleepers, back-sleepers, lighter/average weight adult side-sleepers and children

Evaya is a new entrant to the organic mattress market. We were introduced to the brand when they reached out to ask our team’s opinion on sustainability options for their packaging. We were so impressed with the product that we decided to carry the Evaya brand in our online store. Our readers are concerned with off-gassing and VOCs, and Evaya carries both Made Safe and Eco-Institut certifications, which means it is guaranteed to be free of even trace amounts of toxic chemicals.

our experience with evaya bliss

We have tested the Evaya Bliss, which is similar in build to the Avocado mattress Plush line. The Evaya Bliss is built with extra comfort layers of EverEden wool to help keep the mattress cool. The wool is Wool Integrity certified and sourced from farmers in New Zealand.

2

Avocado Green Mattress [Staff Tested]

Leaf Score

VOC-free, Made Safe Certified, will never off-gas, made by hand in the U.S.

View on Avocado

At a glance:

• Materials: Organic Fair Trade cotton, organic wool, organic Dunlop latex, upcycled steel coils 
• Certifications: GOTS, GOLS, Made Safe, GreenGuard Gold, Climate Neutral certified, FSC, Responsible Wool Standard, Formaldehyde Free (UL), Eco Institut, Fair Trade, 1% for the Planet, B Corporation, Sustainable Furnishings Council
• Sleep Trial: 365-night sleep trial
• Firmness: Gentle-firm (or medium-firm)
• Best for: Stomach-sleepers, back-sleepers, lighter/average weight adult side-sleepers and children

I chose curbside delivery which was fine but this mattress in King size is a BEAST. I have a hand truck and it was the only way I believe it could be moved upstairs. I’d recommend carefully evaluating your abilities, skill sets, and your available tools if choosing this option is your inclination.

Martin C., 2022

The Avocado Green signature mattress is a medium-firm or gentle-firm (with pillow-top) mattress that is vacuum sealed in plastic and then wrapped in paper and protected by a cardboard box. This makes it one of the most sustainably packaged options for a doorstep boxed mattress that’s relatively easy to move around.

Unlike many organic foam latex mattresses, no assembly is required with the Avocado Green Mattress.

The Avocado Green mattress is certified by Made Safe, meaning it has been tested and is verified free of a huge number of toxic materials and chemicals. Avocado is also an industry-leading Benefit Corporation (B Corp), is certified Fair Trade and Climate Neutral (and is, in fact, carbon negative). The company is also a 1% for the Planet member (and winner of the Pinnacle Award) and is close to operating world’s first certified zero-waste mattress factory.

The Avocado Green mattress is a GOTS certified latex hybrid mattress with up to 1,414 individually wrapped 8-inch innerspring coils and either two or four inches of GOLS certified organic latex on top.

The mattress is free of flame retardants and chemicals, with organic wool and organic cotton surrounding the latex and innersprings.

Unlike the Eco Organic, the Green Mattress includes a 1-inch layer of latex on the bottom of the mattress for a more robust build.

Avocado sources the GOTS organic wool from a farmer’s society it co-owns in India, and only uses wool certified to the Responsible Wool Standard. The Avocado Green is firmer for a latex hybrid mattress, at 7/10 without the pillow top and 6/10 with the topper.

our experience with the avocado green mattress

The LeafScore team has been fortunate to tour the Avocado retail store in La Jolla, CA once a year for the last several years to stay up-to-date on all the latest offerings by Avocado, and to get a chance to touch and feel textures and materials.

3

Happsy Organic Mattress

Leaf Score

Super affordable, non-toxic, organic mattress with Made Safe certification. Hybrid coil and latex mattress with little motion transfer and plenty of support where you need it. Pillow-top available.

View on Happsy

At a glance:

• Materials: Organic cotton, organic wool, organic latex, recycled steel coils wrapped in polypropylene
• Certifications: GOTS, GOLS, Made Safe, GreenGuard Gold, UL Formaldehyde Free, Zero Toxics Product Registry, Rainforest Alliance, FSC, Green America certified business, 1% for the Planet, Sustainable Furnishings Council,
• Sleep Trial: 120-night sleep trial
• Firmness: Medium-firm
• Depth: 10-inch
• Best for: Stomach-sleepers and average weight back-sleepers

Love it! I sleep so well on it and feel great when I wake up. Service was great. Huge improvement on my previous toxic foam mattress.

AP., 2021

2 weeks in and absolutely loving this mattress. I am a stomach sleeper and was motivated to buy a new mattress to help with my lower back pain. My husband is a side/back sleeper and he likes it too. I have woken up feeling rested and completely back pain free. I chose this mattress because of the health certifications and am working to eliminate toxins from our home. I only wish it came not wrapped in plastic – we aim to be plastic free wherever possible. Hopefully you find an alternative packing solution soon. Overall we absolutely love it.

Ashley O., 2021

If you haven’t heard of Happsy, let us introduce you. This company was founded by Naturepedic, one of our favorite mattress makers. The basic idea is that by offering a single mattress option and piggybacking on Naturepedic’s high volume orders for materials and manufacturing, Happsy provides a super affordable mattress-in-a-box that is also certified organic, eco-friendly, and non-toxic.

A Happsy mattress won’t work for everyone and can’t be customized, but if it works for you, get ready to save some cash!

Happsy offers one 10-inch organic mattress combining organic Dunlop latex and 8-inch pocket coils. The mattress has a layer of organic wool as a natural flame barrier, organic cotton batting on the top, bottom, and sides, and an organic cotton outer cover.

This means you can be sure that the Happsy mattress is free of glues or adhesives, poly-foam, synthetic latex, and fire-retardant chemicals. With some digging, we found that Happsy uses synthetic fabric (polypropylene) to wrap its coils and then heat-seals these. The fabric is zero-VOC certified by GreenGuard Gold and meets GOTS and Made Safe requirements.

Note that the Happsy has a zippered cover. This makes end of life recycling and disposal easier but doesn’t mean you can toggle the comfort layer of your mattress. It also means the mattress top is not stitched in place, which can mean less edge support and structural integrity overall.

4

My Green Mattress Kiwi

Leaf Score

The most affordable eco-friendly Made Safe certified non-toxic organic mattress made with pocket coils and organic latex. Great for kids, teens, and lighter to average weight adults as well as stomach-sleepers and some back-sleepers.

View on My Green Mattress

At a glance:

• Materials: Organic cotton, organic wool, organic latex, steel coils 
• Certifications: GOTS, GOLS, Made Safe, GreenGuard Gold
• Sleep Trial: 365-night sleep trial
• Firmness: Medium-firm
• Best for: Stomach-sleepers and lighter or average weight back-sleepers, children and teens

I am astounded what a difference this amazing mattress makes in my comfort level after sustaining a serious back injury. I switched from a memory foam mattress and with the support of the inner springs of the Kiwi, I am experiencing much improvement in my condition! Also love the ease of set up along with the platform bed, I assembled myself!

Faith W., 2023

The quality of this mattress seems very poor. It is relatively hard, not very comfortable, and feels thin.

Lauren G., 2023

My Green Mattress has seriously upped its game in recent years, with all of its products now made in its own GOTS certified factory. The company is just one of a small number of mattress brands with Made Safe™ certification, meaning its mattresses are truly non-toxic and eco-friendly. My Green Mattress also makes its products in Chicago, helping to keep carbon emissions and the overall environmental footprint low.

It is on the firmer side, however, so best suited for stomach-sleepers, lighter or average weight back-sleepers, children, and teens. It’s likely too firm for most side-sleepers, very petite adults, and older adults requiring greater zoned support at the hips and shoulders. There is a latex pillow-top available ($299 for the Queen size) to soften the overall feel for adults needing greater pressure relief and comfort.

The My Green Mattress Kiwi is a latex hybrid with up to 1,140 individually wrapped pocket coils. This is more than the Avocado Eco Organic.

The 8-inch coils are 13.75 gauge, making them a lot wider than the coils used in most of the Avocado Green mattress and the Eco Organic. This also makes them more durable and sturdy. Given that the coils are already sturdier than those in its competitors’ mattresses, it’s not surprising that My Green Mattress doesn’t use a different coil gauge at the hips or edge. It does, however, add tighter coils in these areas to provide extra support, including 10% more support at the edge.

Above the pocket coil layer is a 2-inch layer of GOLS certified organic and Oeko-Tex certified Dunlop latex with a density of 65 and an Indentation Detection Load of 22-24 (more on this below). Above that is a 1-inch layer of GOTS certified organic wool batting which helps the Kiwi meet federal flammability standards without toxic chemicals or synthetic materials. The cover is made with soft GOTS certified organic cotton.

My Green Mattress doesn’t use toxic glues but does use a zero-VOC water-based latex adhesive to stick its coils together. This meets the standards set by GOTS and GOLS. It then hand-tufts (button-tufts) the layers of the mattress together for greater support and durability. Unlike the Eco Organic and the Happsy, the Kiwi is also sewn together at the top, rather than zippered. This makes it more durable overall and improves the edge support.

The Kiwi is free from toxic chemicals, including flame retardants and poly-foam. It is Made Safe certified and GOTS certified.

5

Avocado Eco Organic [Staff Tested]

Leaf Score

A very affordable, eco-friendly, 10-inch, non-toxic mattress! Made by an award-winning B Corporation with organic latex, wool, and cotton, with recycled steel coils and no toxic chemicals.

View on Avocado

At a glance:

• Materials: Organic Fair Trade cotton, organic wool, organic Dunlop latex, upcycled steel coils  
• Certifications: GOTS, GOLS, Made Safe, GreenGuard Gold, Climate Neutral certified, FSC, Responsible Wool Standard, Formaldehyde Free (UL), Eco Institut, Fair Trade, 1% for the Planet, B Corporation, Sustainable Furnishings Council
• Sleep Trial: 365-night sleep trial
• Firmness: Gentle-firm (5/10)
• Best for: Lighter adults

Super comfortable. It arrived safely very well packed and sleeps great! It’s the best mattress I’ve ever owned. Thank you!

Dawn P., 2022

Didn’t know what to expect from a “boxed” mattress, but the mattress popped “open” immediately after taking the wrapping off. Within in a few hours it was ready to go. Love the feel of the organic material.

Teresa G., 2022

One of the best budget mattress-in-a-box options available, the Avocado Eco Organic mattress starts at just $699 for a Twin and costs just a little more than the My Green Mattress Kiwi at $1,299 for a Queen. It’s also made in the U.S. in a GOTS certified factory by an award-winning B Corp. This Made Safe certified mattress is non-toxic and eco-friendly, is tried and tested (and loved!) by the Leaf Score team, and is a touch softer than the comparably priced Kiwi and Happsy mattresses.

Like most of the mattresses on this list, the Avocado Eco Organic is a latex hybrid made with pocket springs, latex, cotton, and wool. Avocado uses the same 2-inch layer of GOLS certified organic Dunlop latex seen in the Avocado Green but pairs it with a different unit of upcycled steel coils. This is the main difference between the two.

The Eco Organic has up to 988 double-tempered 8-inch recycled steel coils in two gauges (14.5 at the edge; 12 for the interior). Overall, there are fewer coils in this mattress than in the Kiwi, but the gauge is different at the edges and interior. The result is a reinforced edge and softer interior, balancing durability and comfort.

Avocado uses recycled steel rings to keep the layers of the mattress together, avoiding the need for glues or synthetic fiber stitching. My Green Mattress uses latex glue for its coils.

The Eco Organic doesn’t have the additional bottom 1-inch layer of latex as seen in the Avocado Green, giving it a 10-inch profile rather than 11 inches. The comfort layer comprises D65 / 14-19 ILD, soft Dunlop latex sourced sustainably as detailed in the Avocado Green review above.

You’ll find GOTS certified organic cotton ticking for the softer top cover and organic cotton canvas on the base. Avocado also uses GOTS certified wool batting to meet federal safety standards.

The mattress is certified non-toxic by Made Safe, and includes no flame retardants or other toxic chemicals, no adhesives, fiberglass, of poly-foam.

Honorable Mention

The mattresses below made our list for suitable organic options, but lack Made Safe Certification so we have included them in the Honorable Mentions section.

6

PlushBeds Luxury Bliss

Leaf Score

A latex hybrid mattress available in medium and medium-firm, suiting a wide range of sleep styles and available in split-sizes with different firmness ratings. GOTS, GOLS, GreenGuard Gold, and Eco Institut certified. Excellent choice for reduced motion transfer and edge support, and for heavier adults.

View on PlushBeds

At a glance:

• Materials: GOTS cotton, GOTS wool, GOLS latex, steel coils
• Certifications: GOTS, GOLS, GreenGuard Gold, Eco Institut (latex), GreenGuard Gold
• Sleep Trial: 100-night sleep trial
• Firmness: Medium / Medium-Firm / dual firmness option
• Best for: Stomach-sleepers and back-sleepers (med-firm), side-sleepers (medium)

We got so fed up with the marketing hype and costs of good mattresses we decided to try Plush Beds in medium 12″ inner spring. We’re both in our late 50’s and don’t sleep well, and this mattress has made a huge difference. We don’t like the support of a plain latex, and it’s too warm. This mattress is just right.

Anonymous, 2021

PlushBeds is a staple on many of our mattress lists because we have used the Botanical Bliss extensively and sent a latex sample to Duke University to confirm it was free of flame retardants.

Available in medium-firm and medium, and with dual-firmness to suit couples with different needs, the PlushBeds Luxury Bliss mattress is a fantastic mattress-in-a-box made by a sustainable company.

PlushBeds offers a white glove delivery service and mattress removal (for a fee) and has a lifetime warranty for its Luxury Bliss mattress as well as a 100-night sleep trial.

The PlushBeds 12-inch Luxury Bliss is a latex and coil hybrid mattress with up to 1,283 steel coils. This means it has slightly fewer coils than the Avocado Green, though PlushBeds also reinforces the edges of the mattress with more coils with a different gauge for added stability. The coils are individually wrapped in fabric for reduced motion transfer and better comfort and support.

PlushBeds uses GOLS certified organic latex, with three inches of Talalay latex on top of the 8-inch coils. The top and bottom of the mattress comprises a 1-inch GOTS certified organic cotton cover with GOTS wool batting made of Joma New Zealand wool as a natural fire barrier.

The Luxury Bliss is sewn together, with no adhesives, chemical flame retardants, or other toxic chemicals used in its manufacture. PlushBeds uses a circular-knit organic cotton cover for greater support and pressure relief.

If you’re looking for a firmer mattress in a box, the Luxury Bliss is a fantastic choice. The medium-firm is an 8/10 for firmness, which is great for stomach-sleepers but not usually comfortable for side-sleepers or back-sleepers.

Luckily, you can also choose the PlushBeds Luxury Bliss in a medium firmness, rated at 5.5/10. This is a much better option for side-sleepers and back-sleepers but will usually be too soft for stomach-sleepers of any size.

The Luxury Bliss is also available in split sizes (from Queen up) and PlushBeds lets you choose different firmness options for both sides. This makes for a great compromise mattress for couples with different sleep needs. You can also use the Luxury Bliss mattress with all bed types, including adjustable bases.

We love that the Luxury Bliss has four or six (in larger sizes) very sturdy (but inconspicuous) handles stitched onto the sides. This makes the mattress more user friendly to move (and to setup) and is one practical reason we added this model to our list.

7

Birch Luxe Natural Mattress

Leaf Score

Highlights: Well-designed latex 11.5-inch hybrid mattress with zoned support at the shoulders and hips and extra edge support. Ideal for hot sleepers and stomach sleepers, including heavier adults. Made with sustainably sourced and organic materials and certified GOTS and Greenguard Gold.

View on Birch Living

At a glance:

• Materials: Organic Fair Trade cotton, organic wool, organic cashmere, Talalay latex, steel coils 
• Certifications: GOTS, GreenGuard Gold, Rainforest Alliance (latex), Fair Trade (cotton)
• Sleep Trial: 100-night sleep trial
• Firmness: Medium-firm
• Depth: 11.5-inch
• Best for: Stomach-sleepers and back-sleepers

The first night I slept on the Birch Luxe, it was a perfect sleep – no morning tension, no tossing and turning all night, no insomnia. I look forward to sleep every night now. My husband finds it equally satisfying. I never thought this was possible. It’s all organic, to boot !!

Alicia B., 2022

The Birch Luxe Natural is a good choice of a non-toxic mattress-in-a-box especially if you’re a heavier adult or older adult in need of a touch more shoulder and hip support. This zoned latex hybrid mattress is comfortable, breathable, and has reinforced edging on all four sides, with a higher coil count and three comfort layers, including one made with organic cashmere.

The Birch Luxe Natural is a latex hybrid mattress made with Talalay latex. This makes it a softer mattress overall compared to the Dunlop latex Kiwi, Happsy, and Avocado Green. Lest you worry this mattress will be too soft, though, note that the layer of latex is actually quite thin and is topped by three layers of organic wool and cashmere. The overall effect is a supportive but comfortable sleep surface that offers superior temperature regulating and moisture-wicking abilities. The Luxe Natural has a quilted Euro-Top made of GOTS certified organic cotton. On the bottom of the mattress there’s a layer of organic wool and the organic cotton cover.

As for the innerspring unit, this comprises more than 1000 individually wrapped pocket coils that move independently to offer inch by inch support. The Luxe Natural is also a zoned mattress, with extra support at the hips and shoulders and extra coils to reinforce all four sides.

The Birch Luxe Natural is a great choice for heavier adults who like to sleep on their stomach. It is also a good option for older adults requiring greater support at the hips and shoulders. Those extra comfort layers make for a soft sleep surface with excellent support beneath.

FAQs